Free cookie consent management tool by TermsFeed

Manage Evaluations

On This Page
This content applies solely to Government Source Selection, which must be purchased separately from the Appian base platform. This content was written for Appian 26.6 and may not reflect the interfaces or functionality of other Appian versions.

After creating a new evaluation, Government Source Selection (GSS) makes it easy to view and manage it on the EVALUATIONS page. You can view all existing evaluations or use search and filter options to find specific ones. Drill down into a single evaluation to see more details or take action.

This page provides a brief overview of how to manage your existing evaluations.

View evaluations

To view your organization's complete list of evaluations in Government Source Selection (GSS):

  1. Click Evaluations on the side navigation bar to navigate to the Evaluations page. The evaluations list displays all existing evaluations and key details about each, including the selected evaluation method, the evaluation's start date, and the due date.
  2. Enter evaluation keywords in the search bar and click SEARCH to filter the evaluation list.
  3. Select the evaluation STATUS (Set up, In Progress, Awardees Selected, or Complete) using the dropdown.
    • Set up: The evaluation has not started. You can update details such as duration, evaluation method, and vendors.
    • In Progress: The evaluation has started. Only limited details such as evaluators, tasks, and documents can be updated.
    • Awardees Selected: Winning vendors are selected, and the evaluation awaits administrative actions and closure.
    • Complete: The evaluation is complete. Only limited details such as tasks and documents can be updated.
  4. Select the evaluation DUE DATE using the date picker.

Evaluations list with search, status, and due date filters

To view evaluation details, click an evaluation in the evaluations list. This displays specific information related to the evaluation:

Evaluation summary view showing key details and sections.

Each evaluation record is organized into the following tabs:

Tab Description
Summary Provides detailed information about the evaluation, including the status, important dates, factors, approach, contracting team members, and more. The default tab when you open an evaluation record.
Vendor Analysis Displays AI-generated analysis of vendor proposal documents organized by vendor and factor. Available to Contracting Officers after the AI analysis is complete.
Factors Provides information about all factors assigned to the evaluation. Expand each factor to see detailed information about any subfactors that have been set up.
Vendors Provides a list of vendors assigned to the evaluation and information about each. Easily search or filter the list to display the vendors you want to see.
Ratings Provides the rating results for each vendor assigned to the evaluation, including the rating method, legend, and any related documents. Filter the rating results to view only the vendors that match your selected criteria or download a summary of the rating results for a specific vendor. You can also view the per-evaluator discrepancy flags and AI-suggested rating.
Consensus Reports Lists all vendor consensus for the evaluation, including the status of each. Clicking the vendor link opens the consensus report, which enables you to start the consensus or view the final report of a completed vendor consensus.
Documents Provides a list of all documents associated with an evaluation record. The Drafts sub-tab displays in-progress Source Selection Decision Document (SSDD) documents. The Documents sub-tab displays finalized documents.
Teams Enables you to view each team assigned to an evaluation and the member names and contact information.
Tasks Provides a list of all tasks associated with the evaluation and sorts them by Outstanding, Completed, Not Needed, and Canceled.
Task History Provides a log of all completed tasks for the evaluation.
Evaluation History Provides a log of all edits, updates, and deletions for the evaluation.

Note:  The Ratings and Consensus Reports tabs apply to best value evaluations, but not to LPTA evaluations.

On the Summary tab, you can also add tasks, upload documents or create a new document from a template, and continue the evaluation setup if necessary.

Need to create a new evaluation? Click Plus iconCREATE NEW EVALUATION to open the guided wizard that walks you through each step of the setup process. See create a new evaluation for more information.

Update evaluations

To update an evaluation in Government Source Selection (GSS), navigate to its summary and:

  • Click Blue Edit icon corresponding to a card to edit evaluation details, description, personnel, and phases.
  • Click Continue Setup in the Factors card to edit evaluation factors.
  • Click Add in the Vendors card to add additional vendors to an evaluation.

Click the edit icons, Add, and Continue Setup to update specific evaluation details.

  • To update an existing vendor:
    1. Click Vertical Ellipsis icon on a vendor card and select Update to open the Update Vendor wizard.

      Navigate to update a vendor.

    2. Update the vendor details and click UPDATE to save changes.

      Update vendor.

  • To delete an existing vendor:
    1. Click Vertical Ellipsis icon on a vendor card and select Delete to open the Delete Vendor wizard.
    2. Click DELETE to delete the vendor.

      Delete vendor.

Note:  If GSS is integrated with Vendor Management (VM) solution, an Update Required tag appears next to the related vendor in GSS when the vendor resubmits a proposal in VM. If a vendor withdraws a proposal after being added to the evaluation, the vendor is removed accordingly.

Update Required tag appears next to the related vendor in GSS when the vendor resubmits a proposal in VM.

Reconcile extracted pricing

When contracting personnel select a vendor document for AI price extraction during the Add Vendors workflow, Government Source Selection (GSS) automatically kicks off the extraction process after the vendors are added. The extraction status is visible on the vendor cards in the evaluation's Vendors section.

View extraction status

Each vendor card displays a status tag indicating the current state of the AI price extraction. The status tags and reconciliation requirements depend on your environment reconciliation configuration.

Note:  The extraction status tag only appears on vendor cards where a document was selected for AI price extraction during the Add Vendors workflow. See Configure mandatory pricing reconciliation to change the reconciliation behavior.

When reconciliation is mandatory (AS_GSS_TOGGLE_EXTRACTED_PRICE_RECONCILIATION_MANDATORY is True):

  • Extracting Pricing: The AI is processing the selected vendor document. No action is required.
  • Review Extraction: The extraction completed without errors. You must review and confirm the extracted pricing on the evaluation Summary tab before starting the evaluation.
  • Reconciliation Required: The extraction completed with errors. You must reconcile the pricing on the evaluation Summary tab before starting the evaluation.

When reconciliation is mandatory, you must reconcile all vendors before starting the evaluation, regardless of extraction outcome.

When reconciliation is optional (AS_GSS_TOGGLE_EXTRACTED_PRICE_RECONCILIATION_MANDATORY is False):

  • Extracting Pricing: The AI is processing the selected vendor document. No action required.
  • Pricing Extracted: The extraction completed without errors. The system applies pricing automatically. No reconciliation action is available on the Summary page.
  • Reconciliation Required: The extraction completed with errors. You must reconcile the pricing on the evaluation Vendors tab before starting the evaluation.

Vendor cards showing the Extracting Pricing and Reconciliation Required statuses.

Vendor cards showing the Review Extraction and Pricing Extracted statuses.

Review and confirm extracted pricing

After the extraction is complete, you can review and edit the extracted pricing data before the system applies it to the vendor's evaluation record. The location of the reconciliation page depends on your environment's pricing reconciliation configuration.

To reconcile extracted pricing of a vendor:

  1. Navigate to the pricing reconciliation page:
    • Mandatory reconciliation (AS_GSS_TOGGLE_EXTRACTED_PRICE_RECONCILIATION_MANDATORY is True): On the evaluation Summary tab, click Vertical Ellipsis icon on a vendor card and select Reconcile Fields to open the Reconcile Fields dialog.
    • Optional reconciliation (AS_GSS_TOGGLE_EXTRACTED_PRICE_RECONCILIATION_MANDATORY is False): On the evaluation Vendors tab, click Vertical Ellipsis icon on a vendor in the grid and select Reconcile Fields to open the Reconcile Fields dialog.

    The reconciliation page displays the AI-extracted pricing data:

    Field Description
    Total Price The overall price extracted from the vendor document.
    Price Breakup Individual line items with item description, quantity, unit price, and total amount.
    Pricing Notes An AI-generated overview of the pricing terms and conditions from the vendor document.

    Pricing Reconciliation page showing extracted total price, line items, and pricing notes.

  2. Review the extracted data and make corrections if needed:
    • Edit the Total Price field directly.
    • Edit individual line item fields (Item Description, Quantity, Unit Price) as needed.
    • Edit the Pricing Notes field to correct or supplement the AI-generated content.
  3. Click SUBMIT to save the pricing data to the vendor's evaluation record.

Tip:  You can return to reconcile vendor pricing at any time by clicking the Reconcile Fields option for a vendor. Pricing data is not finalized until you click SUBMIT.

Update evaluators

If your teams are impacted by personnel or staffing changes, Government Source Selection (GSS) makes it easy for you to reflect those changes by enabling you to update your evaluation teams. Contracting personnel and evaluation chairs can add or delete team members from an evaluation team for any existing evaluations that are still in progress.

Note:  Changes to an evaluator team are not allowed once the evaluation is completed.

To update evaluators for an in-progress evaluation:

  1. Navigate to the evaluation's Summary tab.
  2. Click Blue Horizontal Ellipsis icon and select Update Evaluators to open the Update Evaluators wizard.

    Click ellipses icon and select Update Evaluators to open the Update Evaluators wizard.

    Alternatively, go to the Teams tab and click UPDATE EVALUATORS to open the Update Evaluators wizard.

    Select Update Evaluators to open the Update Evaluators wizard.

  3. Select the evaluator team to update from the list on the Teams panel.

    Evaluator team list.

    To add evaluators:

    1. Click ADD EVALUATORS.
    2. Select evaluators using the Search for Evaluators multi-select auto-suggest dropdown.
    3. Click ADD to add the evaluators.

      Search and add evaluators.

    To remove evaluators:

    1. Select the evaluator checkboxes.
    2. Click REMOVE EVALUATORS to remove the selected evaluators.

      Check and remove evaluators as required.

  4. Click NEXT.
  5. Verify that the correct evaluators are assigned to each factor and subfactor.
    1. Select Evaluation Team using the dropdown.
    2. Select Evaluators using the multi-select dropdown.
    3. Select the Due date using the date picker.

      Note:  If the due date assigned to each factor or subfactor occurs in the past, you must use the date picker to change it to a future date before proceeding. The future due date you assign must occur before the evaluation due date.

  6. Click UPDATE to update the evaluators.

    Update evaluator fields.

  7. Click CLOSE to close the Update Evaluators wizard.

    Close the Update Evaluator wizard.

Review evaluator ratings

Government Source Selection (GSS) flags any discrepancies in the evaluator ratings, so that you can prioritize your review and address inconsistencies before consensus. You can see the AI-generated rating alongside evaluator-provided ratings, thereby comparing all ratings to get an overall idea of the rating for the vendor-factor.

To review evaluator ratings:

  1. Navigate to the evaluation Summary tab.
  2. Click Ratings.

    The ratings list displays the rating results for each vendor assigned to the evaluation, including the rating method, legend, and any related documents.

    Ratings tab showing ratings for each vendor assigned to the evaluation.

  3. In the Vendor Ratings section, enter the vendor name in the search bar and press ENTER to filter the list.
  4. Select the rating Compliance using the dropdown.
  5. Click Review on an evaluator rating with discrepancies.
    1. View the discrepancies flagged by AI.
    2. View the Rating section for the AI rating and justification.
    3. View the Evaluator Responses for the rating provided by the evaluator.
    4. Close the popup window.

      Factor Chair review popup showing the discrepancy banner, evaluator responses, and AI-suggested rating.

  6. Click Review on Analytical Evaluator to review the vendor analysis from AI.

Generate SSDD

Once all evaluation factors are marked as complete in Government Source Selection (GSS), contracting personnel can generate a Source Selection Decision Document (SSDD) using the AI Document Builder. The AI Document Builder compiles vendor consensus data into a structured draft that you can review, edit, and finalize.

To generate an SSDD:

  1. Navigate to the evaluation Summary tab.
  2. Click Blue Horizontal Ellipsis icon and select Generate SSDD.

    Generate SSDD action on the evaluation summary.

    The Create Source Selection Document screen displays with options to add relevant documents and supporting notes along with the vendors that will be included in the SSDD.

    The Create Source Selection Decision Document screen displays list of vendors, template preview, and options to attach documents and notes.

  3. Review the listed vendors.

    • You can select the vendors using the checkbox adjacent to each vendor when there are more than 10 vendors for the evaluation.
  4. (Optional) If you need to attach supporting documents, click Select to select those documents or click Upload to add any new documents. For example, you can add the source selection plans.
  5. (Optional) Enter Note in the Add supporting notes section. To add another note, click Add new note and enter the notes. For example, you can add the meeting or discussion notes.
  6. Review the Template Preview.
  7. Click GENERATE DRAFT.

    The SSDD draft generation confirmation screen displays.

    SSDD draft generation confirmation screen with information about the status of SSDD generation.

    The AI Document Builder processes the document. Once generation is complete, the draft appears in the Drafts sub-tab on the Documents tab in the evaluation summary.

  8. Click DONE.

Review and finalize SSDD drafts

After the AI Document Builder generates the SSDD draft, you can review and edit it before finalizing.

To review and finalize an SSDD draft:

  1. Navigate to the evaluation Summary tab.
  2. Click the Documents tab.
  3. Click the Drafts sub-tab.
  4. Click a draft document to open and review its contents in preview mode.
  5. Click Vertical Ellipsis icon and select Edit Document.

    Documents tab showing the Drafts sub-tab with in-progress SSDD documents.

    The edit mode screen displays the document details and a banner message about the time taken and number of questions answered by AI in the AI Headstart section. The screen also displays the number of sections pending review, drafted, and number of questions in the template that were answered.

    Edit mode screen showing the AI Headstart banner with sections pending review, drafted sections, and questions answered by AI.

  6. Click a section to view its details.

    Expanded section view showing section details with questions and response fields.

    1. Expand an unanswered question and enter the Response.

      Expanded unanswered question with the Response field for manual entry.

      • Alternatively, you can use the Editing Assistant AI to answer the question.

        Editing Assistant panel showing AI-powered response generation for an unanswered question.

    2. Perform step 6a to answer all the unanswered questions in the section.
    3. Click GENERATE PREVIEW to view the updated document.
  7. Perform step 6 to complete other incomplete sections of the document.
  8. To insert a new section in the document, click + Insert Section at the required position.

    Insert Section option between existing sections in the document outline.

    1. Describe how you want to change or generate text for the new section in the Editing Assistant.
    2. Click GENERATE PREVIEW to view the updated document.

      Editing Assistant generating text for a new section with the updated document preview.

  9. Click SAVE to save your changes.

    • Note: To edit the document again, you need to navigate to edit mode screen from the Drafts sub-tab.
  10. Click FINALIZE AND EXPORT to finalize the document.

Finalize and Export button on the document edit screen to complete the SSDD draft.

The document moves from the Drafts sub-tab to the Documents sub-tab.

Note:  You can generate multiple SSDD drafts for the same evaluation. Each draft appears in the Drafts sub-tab until finalized.

Select awardees

In Government Source Selection (GSS), for best value evaluations, after all factors are marked as complete, contracting officers and evaluation chiefs can select the winning vendors through the Select Awardees action.

To select winning vendors:

  1. Navigate to the evaluation Summary tab.
  2. Click Select Awardees.

    Evaluation summary page showing the "Select Awardees" link in the Vendors section.

  3. Select one or more vendors based on the evaluation's award type:
    • Single Award: Select one winning vendor.
    • Multiple Award: Select multiple winning vendors.
  4. Click SUBMIT.

    Select Awardees dialog showing vendor selection interface with checkboxes to select the winning vendors.

After you select vendors, the evaluation status changes to Awardees Selected. When the evaluation is created from a solicitation in Government Contract Writing (GCW), all the vendor-submitted documents, for both awardees and unsuccessful vendors, are automatically attached to the related solicitation record for a complete audit trail and future reference.

Evaluation summary page after awardee selection showing the status changed to "Awardees Selected".

View vendor analysis

After an evaluation is started in Government Source Selection (GSS), the requirements extraction begins where AI extracts the solicitation requirements from the evaluation title, evaluation description, factor description, instructions, and the solicitation text from Government Contract Writing (GCW). After the requirements extraction is complete, the vendor response analysis can be initiated by the Contracting Officer for a maximum of 10 vendors at a time. Contracting Officers can view the results in the Vendor Analysis tab on the evaluation summary.

Note:  The Vendor Analysis tab becomes available for best value evaluations after the AI completes the analysis.

To view the vendor analysis:

  1. Navigate to an evaluation summary.
  2. Click the Vendor Analysis tab.

    Vendor Analysis tab showing vendor cards and findings summary.

    The tab displays all vendors you selected for the evaluation.

  3. Click a vendor to view the detailed analysis.

    The vendor analysis view displays:

    • Overall Summary: A high-level summary of the vendor's response across all factors.
    • Factor Analysis: A list of findings organized by factor. Each finding includes:

      Field Description
      Summary A detailed summary of the factor-wise findings.
      What A brief label identifying the high-level category of the finding.
      Text What the vendor stated or demonstrated in their response.
      Source The document name, section, and page where the finding was identified.

    Detailed vendor analysis showing overall summary and factor-wise findings.

  4. Click a Source link to open the referenced document at the specific section and page in a popup.

    Source link popup navigating to the referenced section in the vendor document.

Create awards

When you have the Government Contract Writing (GCW) solution in your environment and an evaluation is created from a solicitation in GCW, you can create awards in Government Source Selection (GSS) after the awardees are selected. You can create an award for an awardee or create multiple awards for multiple awardees simultaneously.

Create single award

To create an award for an awardee in an evaluation:

  1. Navigate to an evaluation summary.
  2. In the Awardees section, click Create Award for the awardee for whom you want to create the award.

    Create Award option in the Awardees section in the evaluation summary.

    The solicitation details automatically populate in the corresponding award fields. You can update the details as necessary, except Instrument Type and Multiple or Single Award IDV fields.

    Create Award dialog with pre-populated solicitation details.

  3. Update the award details as necessary.
  4. Click CREATE.

    Award creation confirmation message.

    Clicking the award link displays the award summary in GCW.

  5. Click CLOSE to return to the evaluation summary.

    The status of the award changes to Created in the evaluation summary. You can click View Award to view the award details in GCW.

    Award status changed in the evaluation summary.

Create multiple awards

To create multiple awards for awardees in an evaluation:

  1. Navigate to an evaluation summary.
  2. In the Awardees section, select the awardee checkboxes.
  3. Click CREATE AWARDS.

    Create Awards button in the Awardees section in the evaluation summary.

    The solicitation details are automatically populated in the corresponding award fields. You can update the details as necessary, except the Instrument Type field.

    Create Awards dialog with pre-populated solicitation details.

  4. Update the award details as necessary.
  5. Click CREATE AWARD(S).

    Multiple awards creation takes a few minutes to complete.

    Awards creation inprogress message.

  6. Click CLOSE to return to evaluation summary.

    The status of the selected awards changes to Created in the evaluation summary.

Complete evaluations

After winning vendors have been selected, contracting officers can complete the evaluation in Government Source Selection (GSS).

To mark an evaluation complete after all factors are complete and the evaluation status is Awardees Selected:

  1. Navigate to an evaluation summary.
  2. Click Blue Horizontal Ellipsis icon and select Complete Evaluation to open the Mark Evaluation Complete wizard.

    Options menu showing 'Complete Evaluation' highlighted.

  3. Select the Completion Date using the date picker.
  4. Click COMPLETE EVALUATION to complete the evaluation.

    Mark Evaluation Complete wizard with date selection.

Delete evaluations

To delete an evaluation in Government Source Selection (GSS):

  1. Click Evaluations on the side navigation bar to navigate to the Evaluations page.
  2. Click an evaluation record to navigate to its Summary page.
  3. Click the … more options dropdown.
  4. Select Delete to open the Delete Evaluation wizard.
  5. Enter the Reason for deletion.
  6. Click DELETE.

Caution:  Evaluations cannot be recovered once deleted. Any associated data such as documents and tasks are also deleted.

Click ellipses icon and select Delete to delete an evaluation.

To view an evaluation's related solicitation in Government Source Selection (GSS):

  1. Click Evaluations on the side navigation bar to navigate to the Evaluations page.
  2. Select an evaluation to navigate to its Summary tab.
  3. In the Solicitation card, click the solicitation to navigate to its summary.

Note:  The Solicitation card is read-only for non-contracting personnel.

GSS evaluation summary showing Solicitation card.

To view an evaluation's related opportunity in Government Source Selection (GSS):

  1. Click Evaluations on the side navigation bar to navigate to the Evaluations page.
  2. Select an evaluation to navigate to its Summary tab.
  3. In the Opportunity card, click the opportunity to navigate to its summary.

GSS evaluation summary showing Opportunity card.

Feedback